MVP Winners: 1957-1970

1970
Winner
49ers quarterback John Brodie (33 votes)
Runners-up
Raiders quarterback George Blanda (27 votes)
Vikings quarterback Fran Tarkenton (3 votes)
Vikings defensive tackle Alan Page (3 votes)
Bills quarterback Daryle Lamonica (unknown)
Bears linebacker Dick Butkus (unknown)
Lions tight end Charlie Sanders (unknown)
Vikings defensive end Carl Eller (unknown)
Lions linebacker Mike Lucci (unknown)
Bills wide receiver Marlin Briscoe (unknown)
Giants running back Ron Johnson (unknown)
Rams defensive tackle Merlin Olsen (unknown)
Dolphins defensive tackle Manny Fernandez (unknown)

1969
Winner
Rams quarterback Roman Gabriel (21.33 votes)
Runners-up
Vikings quarterback Joe Kapp (8.33 votes)
Vikings defensive end Carl Eller (7 votes)
Cowboys running back Calvin Hill (4.33 votes)
Redskins quarterback Sonny Jurgensen (4 votes)
Rams defensive end Deacon Jones (1 vote)
Bears linebacker Dick Butkus (1 vote)
Lions defensive tackle Alex Karras (1 vote)

1968
Winner
Colts quarterback Earl Morrall (33 votes)
Runners-up
Browns running back Leroy Kelly (5 votes)
Browns quarterback Bill Nelsen (4 votes)
Colts tight end John Mackey (1 vote)
Bears linebacker Dick Butkus (1 vote)
Cowboys defensive tackle Bob Lilly (1 vote)
Bears running back Gale Sayers (1 vote)

1967
Winner
Colts quarterback Johnny Unitas (40 votes)
Runners-up
Rams defensive end Deacon Jones (3 votes)
Browns running back Leroy Kelly (2 votes)
Bears running back Gale Sayers (2 votes)

1966
Winner
Packers quarterback Bart Starr (19 votes)
Runners-up
Cardinals safety Larry Wilson (6 votes)
Cowboys quarterback Don Meredith (4 votes)
Browns running back Leroy Kelly (3 votes)
Bears running back Gale Sayers (2 votes)
Packers cornerback Willie Davis (2 votes)
Cowboys defensive tackle Bob Lilly (1 vote)
Redskins quarterback Sonny Jurgensen (1 vote)
Colts tight end John Mackey (1 vote)
Cowboys running back Dan Reeves (1 vote)

1965
Winner
Browns running back Jim Brown (34 votes)
Runners-up
Colts quarterback Johnny Unitas (3 votes)
49ers wide receiver Dave Parks (2 votes)
Bears running back Gale Sayers (1 vote)
49ers running back Ken Willard (1 vote)
Eagles tight end Pete Retzlaff (1 vote)

1964
Winner
Colts quarterback Johnny Unitas (32 votes)
Runners-up
Browns running back Jim Brown (5 votes)
Colts running back Lenny Moore (2 votes)
Bears wide receiver Johnny Morris (1 vote)

1963
Winner
Giants quarterback Y.A Tittle (33 votes)
Runner-up
Browns running back Jim Brown (7 votes)

1962
Winner
Packers running back Jim Taylor (19 votes)
Runners-up
Giants quarterback Y.A. Tittle (13 votes)
Redskins running back Bobby Mitchell (4 votes)

1961
Winner
Packers running back Paul Hornung (unknown)
Runners-up
Packers running back Jim Taylor (unknown)
Redskins quarterback Sonny Jurgensen (unknown)
Browns running back Jim Brown (unknown)
Giants wide receiver Del Shoftner (unknown)
Giants quarterback Y.A. Tittle (unknown)
Packers quarterback Bart Starr (unknown)

1960
Winners
Eagles quarterback Norm Van Brocklin?? (unknown)
Lions linebacker Joe Schmidt?? (unknown)

1959
Winner
Colts quarterback Johnny Unitas (20 votes)
Runners-up
Giants quarterback Charlie Conerly (7 votes)
Browns running back Jim Brown (5 votes)
Giants linebacker Sam Huff (3 votes)
Colts wide receiver Raymond Berry (1 vote)
49ers running back J.D. Smith (1 vote)

1958
Winner
Browns running back Jim Brown (22 votes)
Runners-up
Colts quarterback Johnny Unitas (15 votes)
Lions quarterback Bobby Layne (1 vote)
Colts running back Lenny Moore (1 vote)
Giants linebacker Sam Huff (1 vote)
Giants defensive tackle Roosevelt Grier (1 vote)

1957
Winner
Browns running back Jim Brown (14 votes)
Runners-up
49ers quarterback Y.A. Tittle (10 votes)
Colts quarterback Johnny Unitas (7 votes)
Lions linebacker Joe Schmidt (3 votes)
49ers wide receiver Billy Wilson (1 vote)
Rams guard Duane Putnam (1 vote)

2011-2016 | 2001-2010 | 1991-2000 | 1981-1990 | 1971-1980 | 1957-1970 | AFL (1960-1969)